I recently returned from a conference in St. Thomas, USVI, where I moderated a panel on advertising. The session, titled Advertising: The Convergence of Television, Film and Technology, included an attorney from Microsoft corporation, and a senior executive from Global Grind, a start-up of Russell Simmons, backed by the same investment group that funds Facebook.
The session, which started with a brief Power Point presentation (many thanks to my good friend Ben Tannenbaum for his visuals), segued into a heated discussion of the Microsoft ‘I Am A PC’ spots. Actually, the discussion centered around the efficacy of the first series of commercials launched by Microsoft, which featured Jerry Seinfeld and Bill Gates, and whether Microsoft had intended to lead with those commercials, before unveiling the ‘I Am A PC’ spots.
Several members of the audience thought that Microsoft’s initial spots, were simply crap, and that the ‘I Am A PC’ was a belated effort to offer a more meaningful commercial. Microsoft’s representative (and a few Microsoft ‘ringers’ in the audience) advised that the Seinfeld commercials (I think there were at least 2 that I viewed) were an intentional patsy, or sacrificial lamb, offered to get people talking about how bad they were. According to him, the point of those commercials, were that they were…how to put this?…pointless.
For anyone who followed Seinfeld, the pointless nature of each episode, was, in fact, the point of the entire show. They were shows about nothing. Similarly, Microsoft explained, the spots were intended to do nothing more than spark discussion about how pointless they were, and to have audiences asking ‘what’s the meaning of all this?’
They specifically didn’t want there to be a single mention of Mircosoft, Vista or anything remotely related to either. More importantly, they didn’t want people talking about Apple. Hence, the spots were not intended as a response commercial to Apple’s many diss ads, which continually punked Microsoft as a clunky out-of-touch company. Rather, they were intended to take the dialogue in a completely different direction.
And when people were just as confused as they could be, the ‘I Am A PC’ spots began airing. The resulting tide of adulation and praise for these commercials, which were full of life and meaning, and the antithesis of the original Seinfeld spots, were Microsoft’s resurrection.
The reason I used the Microsoft commercials in my example, was because whatever you thought of Microsoft, or its operating system, or its commercials, for that moment in time, Microsoft had captured everyone’s attention. It had become the quintessential brand of the moment. When the first commercial aired, the blogsphere was a twitter (no pun intended) with people debating its meaning. Angry posts declared that Microsoft had missed the mark in responding to Apple’s clever ads, and that no one ‘got it’ (whatever ‘it’ was).
Similarly, when the ‘I Am A PC’ dropped several weeks later (after the subsequent Seinfeld spot), the blogsphere was, once again, flooded with bloggers (and regular folks) discussing the Microsoft spot. Over the period of time between the first and last spots, Microsoft claimed that there were literally millions of independent threads online about its ads.
While Apple may be THE brand of the hip cool, current, plugged-in minority, Microsoft (if only for a fleeting moment in time) demonstrated that it had the capacity to be that hip brand (of the dorky majority).
By the end of my session, people were literally up-in-arms, and I thought contentedly (to myself) “well done, my good man. Well done.” After the session that day, and into the next day, people approached myself, and my two panelists, to give us hearty handshakes and thank us for so spirited a session. Law students wanted to know how I got into the business and asked for my card. And a few of the conference planners invited me to moderate sessions in the future. I may be on next year’s planning committee. Shoot, I may have even landed a client.
While Microsoft and Apple will continually be in this war of attrition, I’ll happily pimp them for the benefit of MY brand. ’Nuff said.